Fuel Pumps and Auto Parts Store Returns

Why Fuel Pumps Come Back to the Auto Parts Store

When diagnosis becomes increasingly difficult, our customers are more likely to guess at a solution, and swapping out parts has long been the go-to “quick fix.”

As vehicles become more and more complex, it seems everything has its own module or controller, and fuel pumps are no exception. Fuel-pump returns always have been an issue for parts-store personnel, but the instances of alleged defects have risen as technology has made it more difficult to diagnose and test fuel systems.

High-pressure direct-injection fuel systems, coupled with pulse-width modulated (PWM) fuel pumps, have made conventional fuel-pressure tests (formerly done with a gauge and access to a Schrader port on the fuel rail) less common, replaced with scan-tool readings and OBD-code interpretations. Of course, with the reliance on this sort of diagnostic software, lesser-equipped techs and DIYers are left behind, more likely to guess at the root cause of the issue.

Veteran parts specialists remember all too well the days when the cause of a “failed” GM fuel pump was more often related to the wiring harness being scorched or corroded than to the failure of the pump itself. The problem was so prevalent that many aftermarket manufacturers resorted to including a redesigned harness with their new pumps, along with installation instructions. (Raise your hand if you’ve ever heard, “You sold me the wrong fuel pump, it won’t even plug in!”, followed by a mumbled apology after you asked them to check the box for the pigtail.) More recently, it’s the Ford-truck fuel-pump driver module, which has tripped up many a technician who failed to notice the crumbled and corroded aluminum module mounted up tight to the steel frame under the truck bed. Inertia switches and fuel-pump relays also are common causes of fuel-pump misdiagnosis, if somewhat more low-tech than the driver modules and PWM duty-cycle diagnostics. Select Chrysler vehicles have their fuel-pump relay built into the main underhood fuse box (known as a TIPM or PDC). With no external fuel-pump relay, replacement of the entire TIPM/PDC is required when these vehicles stop pumping fuel.


Saddle-style fuel tanks have become an increasingly popular design element for all-wheel-drive vehicles. This design allows for the tank to be mounted away from the rear bumper, reducing the chances of a rear-end collision rupturing the tank. With AWD vehicles, the driveshaft passes under the tank, necessitating the saddle design, as well as requiring twin fuel pumps to siphon fuel from each side of the saddle. Twice the pump, twice the problems … especially when it comes to determining which pump has failed, and which pump is considered primary and secondary among the catalog listings!

When diagnosis becomes increasingly difficult, our customers are more likely to guess at a solution, and swapping out parts has long been the go-to “quick fix.” Unfortunately, we all pay the price for their misdiagnosis or lack of training. Whatever the cause of the misdiagnosis, fuel-pump returns are an increasingly costly problem for both the parts store and the manufacturer. The failure rate for one major aftermarket manufacturer is below 5 percent; however, it has been estimated that at least half of the “defective” returns sent back to them test out perfectly fine, or have been physically damaged during shipping or installation. In addition, nearly 75 percent of the pumps that actually are dead on arrival failed due to outside factors such as fuel contamination, rust and debris from the fuel tank, and similar issues.

You May Also Like

Selling Suspension Conversion Kits

Air-to-coil conversion is a budget-friendly alternative to replacing OE air-ride systems.

Air suspension provides drivers and their passengers with luxurious ride quality, increased safety and load-leveling capabilities. But the high-tech components in an air-suspension system come with high-tech replacement costs.

Chip Lofton, founder of Strutmasters, learned this the hard way.

In 1999, Lofton purchased a 1989 Lincoln Continental. While on vacation, the car’s suspension system failed. Lofton took his beloved Lincoln to a dealership, only to find out that it would cost several thousand dollars to repair the suspension.

VW Automatic Temperature Control

ATC systems require a complex array of sensors that look at the temperature, humidity and air quality inside the vehicle.

What Happened to Throttle-Position Sensors?

Why don’t we see them as often today?

Wheel Bearings and Geometry

The pre-load determines the exact location at which the roller balls will contact the inner and outer races.

Mapping Out the Future of the Global Aftermarket

Distribution leaders discuss the value of being part of NEXUS Automotive International.

Other Posts

Seasonal Sales Opportunities

With each new season, we’re presented with different challenges and different sales opportunities.

Brake Rotors: Resurface Or Replace?

With any rotor problems, unless it makes economic sense to resurface, just replace them.

Making The Case For ADAS

As real-world testing of autonomous vehicles begins, the technology is encountering some pretty significant speed bumps.

Loaded Struts: What’s In A Name?

Loaded strut assemblies are known by many monikers, but they all offer a common advantage: ease of installation.